ESPP 2025

Is Experimental Philosophy Ready for Meta-Analyses?

Poster presented at ESPP 2025 on reporting quality in experimental philosophy and its consequences for future meta-analyses.

The poster introduces the X-PHI Transparency & Quality of Reporting Inventory, a coding tool with about 100 questions covering transparency, theoretical background, methods, results, and conclusions.

It reports on a stratified sample of 400 papers drawn from PhilPapers (2007-2024) and asks whether experimental philosophy currently reports enough detail for replication, data reuse, and meta-analysis.

Open poster PDF Download poster

Project resources

X-PHI Transparency & Quality of Reporting Inventory
Coding tool for assessing reporting quality in experimental philosophy, with linked explorer, OSF record, and study repository.

Research team

Bartosz Maćkiewicz
Katarzyna Kuś
Joanna Gęgotek
Monika Gurak
Franciszek Kittel

X-PHI TQRI

Interactive access credentials

Use the username espp2025 and the password espp2025 to explore the interactive inventory.

Questions, feedback, and collaboration: b.mackiewicz@uw.edu.pl.

Open resource page